Sellfy vs Gumroad vs Payhip: Best Storefront for Selling VRChat Avatars (2026)

seabug
seabug
January 29, 2026 14 views

If you sell VRChat avatars, props, and clothing packs, you want three things: clean checkout, good marketing tools, and fees that do not crush you as you scale.

The comparison that matters

Pricing, fees, and tax handling

Platform Monthly cost Platform fee per sale Payment processing
Sellfy Free trial + Paid plans No Sellfy transaction fee Stripe or PayPal fees still apply
Gumroad $0 10% + $0.50 per transaction Processing fees still apply
Payhip Free or paid plans Free: 5% Plus: 2%

Files and delivery limits (important for big avatar packages)

Platform Practical note for VRChat creators File limits and notes
Sellfy Good for large bundles if you ship a Unitypackage plus docs, plus extras Up to 50 files per product. Combined size up to 10GB (Starter) or 20GB (Business or Premium)
Gumroad Works fine for zips and Unitypackages, but check your product size expectations Limits vary by product type and account. Most creators keep it simple with one zip or one Unitypackage
Payhip Works well for zips and clear delivery, common for digital assets No hard number listed on the pricing page, but Payhip supports typical digital delivery workflows. Keep packages clean and documented

Selling features that actually increase revenue

Feature Sellfy Gumroad Payhip
Discount codes Yes Yes Yes
Upsells or cross-sells Yes Yes Yes
Email marketing built-in Yes Not positioned as core feature Yes
Subscriptions Yes Yes Yes
Storefront feels like a real shop Strong Medium Strong

What to sell for VRChat, and how to structure it

The simplest structure that matches buyer behavior:

  • Flagship product: a complete avatar that is ready to upload
  • Add-ons: props and clothing packs
  • Bundles: avatar + add-ons at a discount

Why this works: buyers want one-click value first, then they buy extra looks and accessories later.

My take

If you want a storefront that feels like a proper shop and does not take a platform cut on every sale, Sellfy is the clean long-term pick.

Sources